All I needed to do was to fix spelling from Mechanic to Machanic in the following post:

SQL Server 2008 T-SQL select hanging, but not dead locked

Unfortunately I could not save my edit, and had to come up with more changes.

I am sure this rule makes sense, but could someone please explain it to me.

Thanks a lot.

share
add comment

1 Answer

up vote 5 down vote accepted

So, to get an idea of the breadth of discussion already on the network for this, I suggest this search on Meta.StackExchange.

Here's the more succint version and more proof that people are against it

But here's the deal: Once upon a time you had to earn reputation privileges to edit ANYTHING. They decided to make the stack more open, and allow anyone to edit. But if you haven't earned a reputation for understanding the community (so your rep score is below 2k), then the community can't yet "trust" you to know what's right. So there are two restrictions in place:

  • Edits must be 6 characters
  • Your edits must be approved by a moderator or two other users

Because an accepted is an increase in the amount of trust in you by the community, you can earn up to 1000 rep from just edit approvals alone, 2 per approval (not 2 per edit vote from two other users since you have to have two users vote your edit as valid, 2 per edit getting approved and being shown as the canonical version of the post).

We moderators keep a pretty close eye on things, so we'll usually approve your edits within several hours. If you need something done sooner, you can always visit chat where there should be someone there with the rep to approve your changes.

Please bear in mind, once you cross the 2k threshold, you can make all the one character edits you want.

share
    
So, if there is a typo in just one character, I should probably just leave a comment, right? –  AlexKuznetsov Jan 27 '12 at 17:07
3  
nope, you should edit it and put six spaces at the end of the post. –  jcolebrand Jan 27 '12 at 17:29
    
adding 6 characters doesn't seem to work.. for example, I wanted to fix the select in dba.stackexchange.com/questions/3815/… by remplacing sysprocesses with sys.sysprocesses and added a bunch of extra spaces but it kept complaining :( –  Kevin May 7 '13 at 14:52
    
I was being silly, actually, but what you should do is just rewrite more stuff. You don't really need to fix one character edits, but the markdown editor doesn't understand some edits. Add double spaces between sentences? –  jcolebrand May 7 '13 at 16:08
add comment

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .